This is an account of the 2007 trial in Nantucket, Massachusetts of Thomas E. Toolan III for the murder of Elizabeth Lochtefeld, daughter of the owners of a local art gallery, on October 25, 2004. The book exhaustively covers thenearly eighteen years from the date of the murder, through two trials, to the affirmation of the defendant's guiltby the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court on September 23, 2022, including the rescript of that decision.